Friday 3 April 2015

What did the televised debates offer workers?



The televised leadership debates offered little hope for workers, apart from the chance to hear from parties representing our Celtic neighbours and the Green Party. Having viewed opinion polls the result of the contest was that most people want the SNP’s Nicola Sturgeon to be Prime Minister nevermind First Minister for Scotland.


But what can we as Liberal Trade Unionists draw from the debate? What was on offer from the Lib Dem leader, Nick Clegg, was not liberalism, it was small c conservatism. It can be clearly seen why the Lib Dems are now regarded by progressives as the ‘Yellow Tories’.


The Greens, Plaid Cymru and the SNP did offer alternatives, but as the old saying goes, the proof of the pudding is in the eating, and although we consider all these parties to be progressive leaning, all have broken their promises on becoming elected, offering ‘austerity light’ measured cutbacks. 


Liberal Trade Unionists do not believe in the austerity message where there are other ways to balance the books. We agree with Labour to an extent that putting people back in employment is the way forward for our country to work and pay its way. But where is Labour or any of the others commitment to full employment? It certainly was not mentioned.


The Liberal Party is committed to full employment. It’s policy states
‘The Liberal Party believes that the quest for full employment cannot be abandoned. It is a paradox of our economic system that while there is a shortage of jobs there is no shortage of work to be done. We do not believe that the solution lies in the creation of a low waged economy nor in “workfare” schemes which force people to work for rates of pay barely above the level of benefits.
However, we do believe that there are options available to the Government which would reduce unemployment significantly. Tackling unemployment must be restored as the top priority of economic management. Investment in training, more flexible working patterns and schemes to bring the long term unemployed back into the mainstream of economic activity are all urgently needed.’

In addition to this the Liberal Party’s General Election manifesto states

‘Liberals call for the introduction of a ‘Workers’ Charter’, clearly defining and safeguarding workers’ and trades union rights. Such a charter would include the right of every worker to join or not to join a union, and democratic procedures for the conduct of ballots. Legislation should be introduced to

make sure employees are involved in fundamental decisions affecting the business they work for, such as mergers and take-overs. There should also be opportunity for employee and community involvement in the running of state owned enterprises’.



As can be seen, what the political leaders put forward in the televised debate was far from the Liberal vision of the Liberal Party and supported by the Liberal Trade Unionists. What was refreshing was the voice given to the Celtic parties and the Greens. We would like to see this voice extended to other smaller parties such as the Liberal Party.